Broadway Market Co, Soho, Manhattan
Broadway Market Co is very possibly the best artisan market in New York City! I always find things that I like! Oh, and you'll typically be greeted at the door by Joel! Sometimes he even dances in the window. They have merchandise new and retro and a great selection. In the back they have a few select food vendors. I have a free sample of amazing dumplings when I entered that Joel was giving out. Whether you live in NYC or you're from out of town, it's definitely a great place to shop and you can support local independent artisans. They're closed on Tuesdays.
Broadway Market Co, 483 Broadway at Broome Street.